Ministerial determination not invalid

My friend Sam Hopper has said in his blog that Judge Anderson in the County Court found that the  Ministerial Determination which effectively excludes premises above the third storey from being “retail premises” was not a valid exercise of power. While Judge Anderson did express the view that it appeared the determination was made without power, His Honour said that he did not consider it necessary to decide the matter.  See: Evans, Tapsall and Van Veen v Thurau Pty Ltd [2011] VCC 1354  at [19].  The  argument put to Judge Anderson was that s 5(1)(f) of the Retail Leases Act 2003 did not come into effect until 1 May 2003 and therefore the Ministerial Determination (which is dated 29 April 2003) could not be valid.  The determination is stated to have been made under s 5(1)(f).  In my view the argument put to Judge Anderson was not correct. The Ministerial Determination says that it does not come into effect until 1 May 2003. Section 5(1B) says that an instrument made under 5(1):

may provide that it has effect on and from 1 May 2003 or such later date (whether before, on or after the date on which the instrument is made) as is specified in the instrument as the date on which it comes into effect.

Sections 13(2) and (3) of the Interpretation of Legislation Act 1984 appear to cure any potential problems. Sam’s blog can be found here

  1. Third floor determination part 3 | Sam Hopper Barrister
  2. Third floor determination | Sam Hopper Barrister

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s


A blog by RICHARD A. FINK, Barrister

Owners Corporations Law

Legal commentary on strata issues in Victoria

The Warne Account

The blog of Dan Warne, Australian tech writer.

Best Practices for Legal Education

A Vision and a Road Map

Tisher Liner FC Law Blog

Legal Updates on Business Law, Property and Litigation



With Compliments

Geoffrey Gibson

The law of land and sea

Australian law of property and environment

Amicae Curiae

Women. Law. Legal Education. Legal Practice. Career. Work/Life balance

Carrie Rome-Sievers, Barrister

Developments in insolvency and commercial law

Equity, Trusts and More

Travis Mitchell, Barrister at the Victorian Bar

The Property Law Blog

Robert Hay QC Property and Commercial Law Barrister

%d bloggers like this: